I agree with you up to a point Jeff, particularly in respect of slotted versus drilled discs point.jeffw wrote:drilled for show and slotted for go (or stop !) is an expression you will hear if you ask brake designers the question, just take a look at the brakes on every front engined racing GT car that has a similar mass to the B5 and you will find slotted discs.
As to heat dissipation, this is a product of the surface area of the rotor (bigger rotors are better), the area of the caliper, design of the rotor veins (if any) and how air is circulated to the brake system. A 2-pot Porsche caliper is unlikely to dissipate heat quicker than a 8-Pot Brembo caliper.
My only concern, relating to my above post, with particular regard to heat dissipation is the pad area - overall the pad surface area is greater on the 2 pad Porsche compared to the 4 pad Brembo - which you seemed to miss in your above post.
The area of the caliper will come into it in a small way, but not as much as the surface area of the pad in comparison. Smaller pad surface area means more heat to dissipate, which would make me stay with the 2 pad Porsche, again IMHO
Cheers,
Andiroo