VAG COM - Serial or USB?
Posted: Wed Jun 29, 2005 12:56 am
I'm looking to buy the VAG-COM cable and do a bit of self-diagnosis before my Audi warranty is up in September. Had a look at previous postings on this site and whilst there seems to be some preference for the serial connector (£149 excl p&p on vag-com.co.uk), there is no negative feedback from those having the USB version. However, in the FAQ section of vag-com.co.uk, I found this:
Q: What if my Laptop doesn't have a Serial Port?
A: We realize some new Laptops don't have Serial Ports, but the ISO-9141 data-link used in VW/Audi cars is so close to traditional "Serial" that it doesn't make sense to use any other kind of port on a PC. If laptop doesn't have a serial port, you'll need to add one. We've had poor results with most USB<->Serial adapters -- therefore USB<->Serial adapters are "Not Supported," If you can get one to work for you, fine. If a USB<->Serial adapter doesn't work, or doesn't work well, please don't ask us for help.
On first reading I thought this said SERIAL GOOD, USB BAD. On re-reading it appears to be saying Serial Good, USB-SERIAL ADAPTOR BAD and USB cable?.....er, No Comment.
Before I take the unprecedented step of spending 150 beer tokens on a piece of cable, I would be grateful for any feedback on both types of cable. My laptop has USB but I can borrow one with a native Serial port from my brother.
Zen
Gi'init Sum Ommer
Q: What if my Laptop doesn't have a Serial Port?
A: We realize some new Laptops don't have Serial Ports, but the ISO-9141 data-link used in VW/Audi cars is so close to traditional "Serial" that it doesn't make sense to use any other kind of port on a PC. If laptop doesn't have a serial port, you'll need to add one. We've had poor results with most USB<->Serial adapters -- therefore USB<->Serial adapters are "Not Supported," If you can get one to work for you, fine. If a USB<->Serial adapter doesn't work, or doesn't work well, please don't ask us for help.
On first reading I thought this said SERIAL GOOD, USB BAD. On re-reading it appears to be saying Serial Good, USB-SERIAL ADAPTOR BAD and USB cable?.....er, No Comment.
Before I take the unprecedented step of spending 150 beer tokens on a piece of cable, I would be grateful for any feedback on both types of cable. My laptop has USB but I can borrow one with a native Serial port from my brother.
Zen
Gi'init Sum Ommer