Much better
Posted: Wed Sep 12, 2007 8:39 pm
I have had my RS4 for just over a week now and 1000 miles and it was back at the dealer for the last few days having its seat reskinned. Meanwhile I had an Audi S5 as a replacement and unlike the two other S5s I had driven in the past this was much better. Most worrying was the fact that it felt more torquey than my RS4 and generally quicker, until I used all of the revs in the RS4.
For anyone who hasn't driven an S5, it is a lovely place to sit, has these great LED DRLs and draws plenty of attention on the road. Downsides are a sloppy gearchange, driveline shunt, inconsistently weighted power steering and an engine that (in my past experience) usually runs out of power beyond mid-range.
This one didn't. It made a great noise, pulled with real urgency and authority in 5th and 6th gears and made me feel rather doubtful of the wisdom in choosing an RS4. Thankfully it undermined this indomitable display as soon as I tacked a twisty back road. That's the time when the S5 shows most clearly that it is a GT car and not a sports car, but I still came away dissapointed that it could make me doubt my RS4.
So I fiddled around last night and decided to disconnect the exhaust valves and see what difference that made. Oh my! What the hell are Audi doing with those exhaust valves.
I had been wondering why the EVO long-termer that I drove to Spain had felt different to my RS4 Avant, and now I know why. It must have had its exhaust valves similarly disconnected. It's like removing a banana that some kid had stuck there as a prank, now the engine breathes, revs cleanly through the gears, sounds the same as the EVO long-termer and behaves identically by triggering TC when changing up from 1st to 2nd at high revs.
It's now a whole different car, noticeably quicker, much easier to drive, louder (in a good way) and a whole lot more appealing. And clearly better than the S5 I had been driving these past few days.
I'm glad I did this, and if anyone else like me was wondering if it was worth doing then wonder no more.
For anyone who hasn't driven an S5, it is a lovely place to sit, has these great LED DRLs and draws plenty of attention on the road. Downsides are a sloppy gearchange, driveline shunt, inconsistently weighted power steering and an engine that (in my past experience) usually runs out of power beyond mid-range.
This one didn't. It made a great noise, pulled with real urgency and authority in 5th and 6th gears and made me feel rather doubtful of the wisdom in choosing an RS4. Thankfully it undermined this indomitable display as soon as I tacked a twisty back road. That's the time when the S5 shows most clearly that it is a GT car and not a sports car, but I still came away dissapointed that it could make me doubt my RS4.
So I fiddled around last night and decided to disconnect the exhaust valves and see what difference that made. Oh my! What the hell are Audi doing with those exhaust valves.
I had been wondering why the EVO long-termer that I drove to Spain had felt different to my RS4 Avant, and now I know why. It must have had its exhaust valves similarly disconnected. It's like removing a banana that some kid had stuck there as a prank, now the engine breathes, revs cleanly through the gears, sounds the same as the EVO long-termer and behaves identically by triggering TC when changing up from 1st to 2nd at high revs.
It's now a whole different car, noticeably quicker, much easier to drive, louder (in a good way) and a whole lot more appealing. And clearly better than the S5 I had been driving these past few days.
I'm glad I did this, and if anyone else like me was wondering if it was worth doing then wonder no more.