Thoughts on S5?

Post by **refurb** » Sat Mar 27, 2010 9:09 pm

Neighbour was chatting earlier, he has a lovely looking S5 which he has owned from new. 2008, covered 15k. I mentioned that i fancied a RS4 and had been looking for one. Turns out he is seeking to sell the S5. He has 20" alloys but, amazingly NO SAT NAV... He didn't think it worth the premium! I've yet to drive an S5 but my understanding is that it has effectively the same engine as the RS4, detuned to 340ish bhp.

How hard is it to tune this engine to RS4 levels-is it just the mapping thats different? Anyone got S5 experience?

Post by **P_G** » Sat Mar 27, 2010 11:02 pm

It's the same engine as in block and FSI, but that's about it. Not just a case of remapping, the RS4 has different throttle bodies, airflow, mapping, cams and a few other bits. Plus the drive of an S5 is way different to an RS4, much more a GT car than a road focused super saloon.

The S5 is a nice car, my mate has one with a full Milltek on it and it decently keeps pace with my RS4 on the motorways but on normal and country roads the S5's bulk and lack of tactility / grunt shows even at below national speed limit levels.

Post by **HYFR** » Sat Mar 27, 2010 11:08 pm

i had a rarce with one to 170 so they are no slouch

But very different to an RS 4

Post by **sonny** » Sun Mar 28, 2010 7:10 am

P_G wrote:It's the same engine as in block and FSI, but that's about it. Not just a case of remapping, the RS4 has different throttle bodies, airflow, mapping, cams and a few other bits. Plus the drive of an S5 is way different to an RS4, much more a GT car than a road focused super saloon.

The S5 is a nice car, my mate has one with a full Milltek on it and it decently keeps pace with my RS4 on the motorways but on normal and country roads the S5's bulk and lack of tactility / grunt shows even at below national speed limit levels.

Is it not the same block that was used in the S4 (not FSI, and 32v vs 40v).

my friend has a S5 looks nice, would not trade the RS4 in for one.

Post by **lynchy** » Sun Mar 28, 2010 8:23 am

very nice looking cars but not that quick

Post by **graemep** » Sun Mar 28, 2010 9:00 am

Have driven both, but to agree with P_G's comment the S5 is more of a GT car and doesn't handle anywhere near as well as the RS4.

Post by **PetrolDave** » Sun Mar 28, 2010 10:56 am

graemep wrote:Have driven both, but to agree with P_G's comment the S5 is more of a GT car and doesn't handle anywhere near as well as the RS4.

The S5 is like the B6/B7 S4 - a boulevard cruiser and not a drivers car (I had a couple of B6 S4's before my RS4 and would never go back).

Post by **Sims** » Sun Mar 28, 2010 11:07 am

sonny wrote: my friend has a S5 looks nice, would not trade the RS4 in for one.

Succint.

I like to think of it is a better frock prima facie, but it's the under pinnings that matter on an ongoing basis...

Post by **grizz** » Sun Mar 28, 2010 3:09 pm

I love the s5 .. A very nice car and not that far behind a rs4 ..The s5 is 30kgs less than the rs4...

Post by **PetrolDave** » Sun Mar 28, 2010 6:05 pm

As I've said before the whole A5/S5/RS5 look out of proportion to me, from the rear they look like a big fat ar*e.

Post by **approved** » Sun Mar 28, 2010 6:55 pm

i'd have an auto one for sloshing about in..great blend of refinement/comfort and speed...

seem to have firmed up quite a bit of late..they were heading towards handy money too...

Post by **klauster** » Sun Mar 28, 2010 7:52 pm

i test drove one before the RS and its slow, and the handling just isn't as good either..

Post by **Nipper** » Mon Mar 29, 2010 10:04 pm

I'm lucky enought to have both, well the S5 is my wifes and I've got the RS. The S5 is faster than you think, but just doesn't feel it. There's no drama, just linear acceleration. Dynamically it's no where near the RS4, but it is a lovely comfortable, fast cruiser, a great GT car. If I want to have fun the RS4 gets the nod everytime. The S5 is a great car, it just has different strenghts to the RS, so don't dismiss it, it just depends on what you want out of a car. Looks wise, especially front on, it's far more aggressive, however the RS has a great behind, and those fabulous arches. Decisions, decisions !!!!

Post by **Sims** » Tue Mar 30, 2010 9:11 am

Nipper wrote:I'm lucky enought to have both, well the S5 is my wifes and I've got the RS. The S5 is faster than you think, but just doesn't feel it. There's no drama, just linear acceleration. Dynamically it's no where near the RS4, but it is a lovely comfortable, fast cruiser, a great GT car. If I want to have fun the RS4 gets the nod everytime. The S5 is a great car, it just has different strenghts to the RS, so don't dismiss it, it just depends on what you want out of a car. Looks wise, especially front on, it's far more aggressive, however the RS has a great behind, and those fabulous arches. Decisions, decisions !!!!

Good summary from a man who is fortunate to run both.

RS246.com Forum :: The World's #1 Audi R, S and RS Enthusiast Community

Thoughts on S5?

Thoughts on S5?

Who is online