Page 1 of 1

Which S4 4.2 (344bhp) or RS4 (380bhp)?

Posted: Wed Jan 25, 2006 12:18 pm
by g7jhp
Hi all I'm gone from an S3 to an old 911 Carrera but am now considering the new stage (family and all that) so an Avant is on the cards.

I loved the sure footed grip and turbo of the S3 so have been toying with the idea of getting an S4 or RS4.

Both seem to be around £22-30k depending on mileage and spec and although the S4 is a newer car is it better to go for an older RS4?

Could I always get a newer S4 and upgrade the bhp to RS4spec?

I'd imagine RS4 will be more £ to run and people will say it depends if like turbo or n/a power.

Any thought would be welcome.

g7jhp

RE: Which S4 4.2 (344bhp) or RS4 (380bhp)?

Posted: Wed Jan 25, 2006 10:34 pm
by Merlot
You won't go wrong with either. I went from a 98 S4 Avant (B5) to an 03 one (B6) when they came out and the difference is immense. RS4 drivers take their cars very seriously and are a very loyal bunch but I prefer the newer S4 with good handling, strong performance, ISOFIX and next stage crash protection.

AMD do S4 upgrades but for me the increased performance with a N/A engine is not enough to get excited about. Anyway, coming from an S3 you will find the S4 very fast with it on a par with a 993.


Lets us know how you get on.