this is the third one on the car now
Anyone else had to replace theres
First one was replaced as it was making a thumping noise which got fairly loud
Bought brand new one from ebay(audi surplus stock) but that went noisey after a couple of months
Got another..yes Ebay but used OK but now just started to get noisey then this morning sounds more like a Dyson then a RS

I can also hear a thumping noise aswell...very strange all was ok for 60k then in the last 6 had 2 secondary air pumps replaced