Update on my £10.5k / 104k mile Noggy...
Posted: Sun Apr 05, 2009 7:54 am
..I've been a bit quiet about my own car following the diagnosis that the hot rattle from front of passenger side head was the cam chain tensioner so here's where I am at the mo;
I knew I had to get the thermostat replaced as it was sticking open so had budgeted for a cambelt job which would only be around 10k miles early and as we were initially thinking it was a belt tensioner rattling it would have killed two birds. However after some probing we realised as suggested on this forum that it was the cam chain tensioner.
Both cam covers were removed (the offside one just to check the cams which were in very good order).
There is a good diagnostic procedure for the chain tensioners in ELSA but we decided it couldn't be anything else so I ordered the part which was around £400. Interestingly ELSA says only start the diagnostics on the tensioner when the engine is above 80 degrees which was exactly the temp when mine would start rattling.
I also ordered all the cambelt parts inc aux belt tensioner.
It took around 4 weeks from initial diagnosis to completion yesterday due to the time pressures of getting together with my RS4 driving mechanic who as you can imagine is in demand especially as he has the correct cam locking tool. On removal the cam chain tensioner had indeed seized, the auxiliary belt tensioner which was probably original was scrap too as was of course the thermostat.
While waiting I took both bumpers to the bodyshop to be repaired and repainted. The front had a crack at the bottom of the nearside air intake and the rear had one near the load lip.
They had to drill all the rivets out to remove the reinforcer from the back bumper to get at the crack but it was all put back perfectly with new speed clips supplied for the screws in the wheel arch.
This is their web site - as an example of their work they are currently working on converting a new shape M3 saloon to an Estate.
http://www.sprintautos.co.uk/
Will post pics of the results but I am very (and not easily) pleased.
On reassembly I got flummoxed trying to pull the headlamp washer jets up to refit the painted square covers as they are really stiff and hard to grip but managed in the end by sticking a small allen key underneath the jet and pulling up.
I removed the black plastic grille inserts from the rear bumper as didn't want them masked out and I am two minds as to whether replace them or use double sided tape to secure them on as the plastic pegs on back are so flimsy that most broke when trying to remove the securing nuts.
Anyone know how much they are? They look cheap but...
I also took the opportunity to fit new clips to the front bumper centre grille which like many wasn't secure all its way around.
The scoops for the intercoolers are rivetted onto the coolers and some of these had been broken when the impact occured to the front bumper so I am in the process of rerivetting these, drilling new holes where needed.
Also got a leak from washer pump which is common - seems to be from the base of the pump.
I should have it all back together by lunchtime today though envisage the front coming off again soon to do washer leak and sort the weird sounding horn but I can live with those for now!
I knew I had to get the thermostat replaced as it was sticking open so had budgeted for a cambelt job which would only be around 10k miles early and as we were initially thinking it was a belt tensioner rattling it would have killed two birds. However after some probing we realised as suggested on this forum that it was the cam chain tensioner.
Both cam covers were removed (the offside one just to check the cams which were in very good order).
There is a good diagnostic procedure for the chain tensioners in ELSA but we decided it couldn't be anything else so I ordered the part which was around £400. Interestingly ELSA says only start the diagnostics on the tensioner when the engine is above 80 degrees which was exactly the temp when mine would start rattling.
I also ordered all the cambelt parts inc aux belt tensioner.
It took around 4 weeks from initial diagnosis to completion yesterday due to the time pressures of getting together with my RS4 driving mechanic who as you can imagine is in demand especially as he has the correct cam locking tool. On removal the cam chain tensioner had indeed seized, the auxiliary belt tensioner which was probably original was scrap too as was of course the thermostat.
While waiting I took both bumpers to the bodyshop to be repaired and repainted. The front had a crack at the bottom of the nearside air intake and the rear had one near the load lip.
They had to drill all the rivets out to remove the reinforcer from the back bumper to get at the crack but it was all put back perfectly with new speed clips supplied for the screws in the wheel arch.
This is their web site - as an example of their work they are currently working on converting a new shape M3 saloon to an Estate.
http://www.sprintautos.co.uk/
Will post pics of the results but I am very (and not easily) pleased.
On reassembly I got flummoxed trying to pull the headlamp washer jets up to refit the painted square covers as they are really stiff and hard to grip but managed in the end by sticking a small allen key underneath the jet and pulling up.
I removed the black plastic grille inserts from the rear bumper as didn't want them masked out and I am two minds as to whether replace them or use double sided tape to secure them on as the plastic pegs on back are so flimsy that most broke when trying to remove the securing nuts.
Anyone know how much they are? They look cheap but...
I also took the opportunity to fit new clips to the front bumper centre grille which like many wasn't secure all its way around.
The scoops for the intercoolers are rivetted onto the coolers and some of these had been broken when the impact occured to the front bumper so I am in the process of rerivetting these, drilling new holes where needed.
Also got a leak from washer pump which is common - seems to be from the base of the pump.
I should have it all back together by lunchtime today though envisage the front coming off again soon to do washer leak and sort the weird sounding horn but I can live with those for now!
